A Thanksgiving Menu for Two

overhead view of Thanksgiving Sheet Pan Meal for Two recipe with turkey breast, stuffing, sweet potatoes, green beans, pumpkin dessert, cranberry sauce, and gravy
Photo: Jessica Furniss

Sharing a Thanksgiving meal for two can be an enjoyable, stress-free experience that allows you to step outside family traditions, try new dishes, and focus on what you are most thankful for. So even if your Thanksgiving is small, you can still have a full holiday meal. These Thanksgiving menu ideas for two feature all the beloved classics. With these recipes, you can enjoy the holiday's best dishes without creating too many leftovers. You'll notice that some of these recipes are specifically designed to serve two, while others are easy to scale down for two people.

01 of 19

Cranberry Stuffed Turkey Breasts

sliced turkey breasts with cranberry stuffing, served on a platter garnished with fresh cranberries
lutzflcat

No need to defrost the whole turkey and spend hours roasting it in the oven. With this excellent recipe, you get both the stuffing and the turkey in one elegant dish. If you have a favorite stuffing recipe, feel free to substitute it for the stuffing mix.

02 of 19

Cornish Game Hens with Garlic and Rosemary

Cornish Game Hens with Garlic and Rosemary
Photo by Jean Ann.

Take a detour from roasted turkey altogether and serve individual game hens this Thanksgiving. Halve the recipe to make two, one for you and one for your dinner companion. The aroma of garlic, rosemary, and lemon, will beautifully permeate your kitchen as the hens roast in the oven in under 90 minutes.

03 of 19

Grilled Turkey Breast with Fresh Sage Leaves

Grilled Turkey Breast with Fresh Sage Leaves
Spunky Buddy

"A new favorite of my husband and mine! The sage leaves make this dish complete," recipe submitter gina.tosso says. You can adjust the number of servings down from eight — or have leftovers to look forward to.

04 of 19

Cranberry Sauce II

cranberry sauce in a glass bowl
SHORECOOK

With just cranberries, sugar, and water, this five-star cranberry sauce couldn't be easier to make or scale down to a smaller serving.

05 of 19

Hasselback Potatoes

tray of three Hasselback Potatoes
bd.weld

As much as one might love mashed potatoes, this method for roasting whole potatoes will earn you extra points for presentation. To prepare these potatoes, you'll start by making thin cuts across each potato without cutting all the way through. When roasted, the slices will fan out slightly and get super crispy. Skip the cheese and breading, and instead spoon your favorite gravy into the crannies of the potato.

06 of 19

Stuffin' Muffins

Stuffin' Muffins
Sheila LaLonde

This Thanksgiving, we encourage you to embrace the love affair with muffin tins and use this trusty kitchen item for stuffing. Allrecipes community member Sheila LaLonde who shares this from-scratch stuffing recipe says, "A traditional stuffing served in fun, individual muffin shaped servings, so you and your guests can enjoy more of the yummy crunchy outsides!"

07 of 19

Thanksgiving Sheet Pan Meal for Two

9408320.jpg

Here's a complete Thanksgiving dinner menu for two baked on a sheet pan! Stuffing, turkey breast, green beans, sweet potatoes, and more — even pumpkin pie! "We're cutting down the prep work," says Jessica Furniss. "Everything cooks together on a sheet pan in about an hour. That includes dessert! We couldn't leave out the pie."

08 of 19

Pear and Pomegranate Salad

salad with pear and pomegranate on a white plate
Annafur

Bring fresh flavor to your Thanksgiving menu with this salad, topped with in-season pears and pomegranate seeds for crunch.

09 of 19

Honey Dijon Brussels Sprouts

Honey Dijon Brussels Sprouts
Photo by AllieGeekPie.

In this recipe, Brussels sprouts are flavored with honey, Dijon mustard, and dill. You can quickly cook these in water until tender as written in the recipe, or roast them in the hot oven. We recommend adding fresh lemon zest to the Brussels sprouts right before serving.

10 of 19

Green Bean Casserole Remix

Green Bean Casserole Remix on a white plate
abbaplez

If you're not a fan of traditional green bean casseroles, take advantage of your small-scale Thanksgiving and make this updated version. You'll taste the difference between frozen green beans, fresh mushrooms, and their canned counterparts. Parmesan and bacon elevate the casserole's flavor, too.

11 of 19

Stuffed Acorn Squash

two halves of stuffed acorn squash
hungryallweighs

Perfectly designed to serve two people, the acorn squash halves are used as vehicles for stuffing. Keep these vegetarian by using vegetable broth, or boost the savory character by adding sautéed crumbled sausage.

12 of 19

Grandma's Corn Bread Dressing

Corn Bread Dressing in a casserole dish
Photo by Allrecipes Magazine.

"This is an excellent recipe if you are familiar with Southern cornbread but never cooked it," says Jeanne Harris Parks, whose review includes several helpful tips. "My grandma told me her secret to good dressing is the vegetables, so use plenty celery and onion. Cook them only until tender and the onions are translucent so you don't lose all the crunch," she says.

13 of 19

Whipped Sweet Potato Casserole

three small bowls of sweet potato casserole
lcday

Along with brown sugar and marshmallows, orange juice sweetens this indulgent side. To preserve the citrus flavor without the extra sweetness, replace the orange juice with the zest of an orange, as reviewer carma174 did.

14 of 19

Pecan Cranberry Butter Tarts

Pecan Cranberry Butter Tarts
Photo by Rob Tanner.

If you're keeping your menu short and sweet and skipping cranberry sauce, these tarts are the perfect combination of one our favorite Thanksgiving dessert (pecan pie) and cranberries. As much as we love individual desserts, we bet you won't be able to eat just one. If you plan on sharing these with children, leave out the brandy.

15 of 19

Mini Apple Pies

Mini Apple Pies
Photo by Reb.

The apple pie filling for these mini beauties is made from Granny Smith apples, lemon juice, nutmeg, and cinnamon and thickened with instant tapioca. If you have a hard time finding instant tapioca, use all-purpose flour in its place. If you are short on time, skip the step of creating a lattice top for the pies and use a crumble topping instead, or simply bake as double-crusted mini pies.

16 of 19

Mini Sweet Potato Pies

mini sweet potato pies on a green tray

The bite-size sweet potato pies are a sweet ending to any dinner. To make them especially festive, top with mini marshmallows and toast under a broiler or with a kitchen torch.

17 of 19

Pumpkin Pie Muffins

Pumpkin Pie Muffins
Photo by naples34102.

You didn't think we'd forget pumpkin, did you? The beauty of this recipe is that it can double up as dessert and breakfast for the day after Thanksgiving. The muffins are baked with pumpkin pie filling, which is a great shortcut for incorporating the traditional pumpkin pie flavor without adding individual spices.

18 of 19

Pumpkin Parfaits

two Pumpkin Parfaits on a counter
Jennifer Triger

Recipe creator Jodster calls this small-scale dessert a "lighter alternative to pumpkin pie." It's easier, too! Layer fluffy, marshmallowy cream cheese and a maple-pumpkin filling before topping each serving with crushed gingersnaps and toasted pecans.

19 of 19

More Like This

Yummy Sweet Potato Casserole recipe topped with chopped nuts in a serving dish
Tamara B.
Was this page helpful?

You’ll Also Love