Grandma's Best Christmas Candy Recipes

Christmas Buttermints - Southern Living — Greg DuPree; Food Stylist: Chelsea Zimmer; Prop Stylist: Christine Keeley.

While you probably don't even think about making homemade candy during the rest of the year, there's just something about the holiday season that'll have you in the kitchen whipping up a batch (or two!) from scratch. These classic Southern candies are even better when they're made with love instead of purchased at the store.

Whether you want to make candy to gift to friends and neighbors, are looking for a recipe to share with your family, or simply want to enjoy it yourself, you can't go wrong with any of Grandma's favorite Christmas candy recipes.

Grab your candy thermometer and the cute Christmas tins, and whip up these homemade candy recipes that you'll love just as much as Grandma does.

01 of 14

Homemade Turtles

To be successful making homemade turtles, we recommend getting your pan ready and having all of your ingredients ready to go as you'll need to work quickly. You'll also want to make sure you have a candy thermometer on hand.

Get The Recipe

02 of 14

Rum Balls

Not only are Rum Balls a favorite of Grandma's but they're also the most-searched Christmas candy in the South. The flavors will continue to develop over time, so they're an easy make-ahead option as well.

Get The Recipe

03 of 14

Potato Candy

Yes, this candy recipe actually starts with a mashed potato! But trust us (and Grandma!), that it can actually be turned into a sweet candy treat.

Get The Recipe

04 of 14

Christmas Butter Mints

It's not a Southern celebration without butter mints! This Christmasy version comes together with no cooking and gets a cheery red color from food coloring. Just make sure to allow plenty of time for them to dry.

Get The Recipe

05 of 14

Cracker Toffee

Ah, saltines! Is there anything they can't do? The versatile cracker is one of the five ingredients used to make this easy candy recipe.

Get The Recipe

06 of 14

Pecan Pralines

A candy thermometer is key to ensuring your pralines come together successfully. Just make sure you're prepared to work quickly once the candy is ready to be set.

Get The Recipe

07 of 14

Stained Glass Candy

Reminiscent of a stained glass window, this classic Christmas candy is almost too pretty to eat. You can use red or green food coloring, or make a batch of both!

Get The Recipe

08 of 14

Saltine Peppermint Bark

If you're looking for a candy that you can make without needing a candy thermometer, this peppermint bark is for you. It just needs at least one hour to chill before it's broken into pieces.

Get The Recipe

09 of 14

Classic Peanut Brittle

When trying your hand at making homemade peanut brittle on the stovetop, just make sure to follow the instructions and keep stirring continuously. We also included directions to make different variations like Pecan Brittle and Chocolate-Dipped Peanut Brittle.

Get The Recipe

10 of 14

Homemade Peppermint Patties

Crushed candy canes make the perfect seasonal garnish to add colors and even more minty flavor to these classic candies.

Get The Recipe

11 of 14

Millionaire Candy

We use premade caramels to help make this recipe for old-fashioned Millionaire Candy a little easier. We suggest using a double boiler to melt the chocolate so that each candy has a nice, shiny finish.

Get The Recipe

12 of 14

Honeycomb Candy

This classic candy comes together with just five ingredients, most of which you probably already have on hand in your pantry during the holiday season. It's not complicated to make, just ensure that you keep an eye on the sugars the whole time they're cooking!

Get The Recipe

13 of 14

Divinity Candy

Not to be confused with meringue, divinity is cooked to a higher temperature to create a candy that has more structure. That means, a candy thermometer is key for the best results.

Get The Recipe

14 of 14

Pulled Candy

If you want to involve kids in the candy making, they can help with the pulling process to make this homemade candy. You can choose to flavor the candy with orange extract, peppermint extract, or make batches of both.

Get The Recipe

Was this page helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!

Tell us why!

Grandma's Best Christmas Candy Recipes

Related Articles